Benefit Badgal Bang! 24 Hour Creamy, Longwear Eye Pencil

Remember the makeup envy you felt at your first rock concert? Well, regardless of your parents’ dress code back in the day, that rocker-chic look can be all yours now. Smoky, smudgy, dark, and oh-so-BAD. BADgal BANG! 24-HR Pencil lasts through it all (and we mean all). It’s waterproof, transfer-proof, and glides on smooth and creamy. Plus, it comes with an automatic, no-sharpen tip and built-in smudger.